Starbucks Autumn Drinks Ranked—Pumpkin Spice Dethroned?

Every August, something magical happens inside Starbucks stores. The fall menu returns, and the world collectively loses its mind. People grab their phones, snap a picture of their drinks, and suddenly your feed is covered in pumpkins, cinnamon, and festive mugs. Honestly, no one even pretends to play it cool. It is a moment, and the moment is always about Starbucks autumn drinks.

The celebrity of this lineup is the pumpkin spice latte. For years, it has been more than a beverage. It has been a seasonal symbol, an icon, practically the definition of fall flavors. But here is the twist. With so many new drinks and creative updates joining the seasonal menu each year, the question is whether the latte still deserves its throne. Or has it become the reliable but maybe slightly usual friend we keep around just for nostalgia?

I am here with answers. I have tried every single drink on this fall menu. I have debated them with my team, overanalyzed every sip, and I am ready to be a little ruthless. Some beverages deserve praise, others deserve a polite side-eye. So if you are ready to sip, argue, and laugh, let’s get into this ranking. Spoiler: my list may have you questioning everything you thought you knew about pumpkin spice.

The Starbucks Autumn Drink Craze

The moment the fall menu drops in august, the vibe changes. People ditch their cold cups of plain iced coffee and immediately flock to grab whatever is topped with pumpkin spice. Sweaters come out, even if the weather still screams summer. Everyone pretends it is crisp outside, while ordering the hottest drinks they can carry. The fall season has officially begun.

There is a reason this obsession is so intense. Starbucks built tradition into the seasonal menu. The pumpkin spice latte is the classic that signals the start of the season, while newcomers like the pecan oatmilk cortado or pumpkin cream cold brew keep things fresh. Every year, the brand is bringing both nostalgia and novelty, and that balance keeps customers hooked. It is not just a cup of coffee. It is a ritual.

And let’s not ignore the fact that this is a limited time deal. These beverages do not last forever. You know once august arrives, your clock is ticking. You have only a few short months to enjoy your pumpkin spice dusting, silky whipped cream, and rich seasonal flavor. That scarcity fuels the hype. By the time holiday baking spices roll in, you will already be planning your first sip of next year’s autumn lineup.

7. Pumpkin Spice Frappuccino

At number ten we have the pumpkin spice frappuccino. This is basically autumn dressed as a milkshake. Picture a mountain of blended ice, syrupy pumpkin spice, and a dramatic swirl of whipped cream. Of course, it is always topped with whipped cream, sometimes even with a pretty dusting of cinnamon or nutmeg. It looks festive and joyful, like the kind of drink you want to hold just to feel cute.

Here is the problem. The flavor is bold and sweet, with vanilla and pumpkin syrup dominating every sip. It tastes fun, but it also tastes like pure sugar. Three sips in, you are questioning your life choices. Is it coffee? Technically, yes. Does it taste like coffee? Absolutely not. It is more like a dessert in disguise, wrapped in pumpkin-scented charm.

The frappuccino makes the list because it is part of the story. It represents the playful, over-the-top side of the fall menu. Kids adore it, adults secretly order it, and it does the job when it is too hot outside for a hot latte. But in the grand ranking of Starbucks autumn drinks, this one is the sidekick, not the star. Cute, fun, but definitely not wearing the crown.

READ ALSO: Fall Decor Ideas That Would Make Martha Stewart Gag

6. Iced Pumpkin Cream Chai Latte

Sliding into ninth place is the iced pumpkin cream chai. This drink is a dramatic, spiced explosion served over ice. Think chai tea mixed with milk, loaded with cinnamon and clove, then topped with a creamy layer of pumpkin cream cold. It is bold, loud, and basically screams fall flavors from the very first sip.

The taste here is complex. You get rich pumpkin spice on top, spicy chai in the middle, and a silky finish of cream. The layers give you an exciting beverage, but let me be honest. It can feel like a lot. After half a cup, it almost feels like the flavor is battling itself. Some customers swear it is the perfect order, while others write one review and never come back to it.

Why does it outrank the frappuccino? Because it has depth. You actually taste spice, not just sugar. The iced version adds freshness, making it more wearable than the frozen option. But it is still not the kind of drink you want every day of the season. It is more like that fun cousin who shows up to the party and keeps things exciting, but you are not building your fall traditions around it.

5. Pecan Oatmilk Cortado

Coming in at number eight is the pecan oatmilk cortado, and let me just say this: if you like your coffee bold, this Starbucks autumn drink deserves your attention. A cortado is naturally small and strong, made with equal parts espresso and milk. Add the nutty twist of pecan, and suddenly this little beverage has an attitude. It is rich, it is punchy, and it is definitely not pretending to be something it is not.

The flavor here is deep and layered. You get the intensity of espresso, then the creamy balance of oatmilk, followed by that smooth pecan finish. The taste notes lean nutty and cozy without feeling too heavy. Compared to something like the pumpkin spice latte, it feels less like dessert and more like a crafted barista creation. It is small, yes, but that is the charm. Sometimes less is more, especially when it packs this much personality.

Still, I cannot put it higher on the ranking because it is not the most versatile. It is amazing for one or two sips, but if you are craving a giant festive cup to last your entire Zoom meeting, this is not it. Think of the pecan oatmilk cortado as the shot of confidence you order when you want something new but still grown-up. It earns its spot, but it will never be the drink of the whole fall season.

4. Pumpkin Cream Cold Brew

At number seven we have the pumpkin cream cold brew, and honestly, this is where the competition starts heating up. This drink has quickly become a fan favorite because it takes everything people love about cold brew and gives it a festive upgrade. You get that bold coffee backbone, then it is topped with a silky layer of pumpkin cream cold. It is smooth, it is rich, and it is definitely less sweet than the pumpkin spice latte.

The beauty of this beverage is balance. The cold brew delivers strong, clean coffee notes, while the pumpkin spice topping softens the edges with sweetness. It is not overwhelming, which makes it a go-to for customers who find the latte too sugary. The flavor is festive, but it still lets the coffee shine, and that is a win in my book. Plus, it looks gorgeous, with the cream floating perfectly over the dark brew.

So why does it land here at seven instead of higher? Because it can be a little one-dimensional. After a few sips, you know exactly what you are getting, and it does not change. That said, this is a strong contender and already a modern classic on the seasonal menu. It feels like the introverted sibling of the pumpkin spice latte: quieter, cooler, and maybe even more stylish. But is it the true ruler of fall? Not yet.

READ ALSO: Pumpkin Spice Coffee: Overrated or Fall Royalty?

3. Pecan Crunch Oatmilk Latte

Sliding into number six is the pecan crunch oatmilk latte, and let me tell you, this one is the surprise guest at the Starbucks autumn drinks party. It is nutty, it is cozy, and it brings a little flair with its crunchy topping. The pecan flavor blends beautifully with oatmilk, giving you a smooth sip that feels like sweater weather in a cup. Add in a touch of rich brown butter and holiday baking spices, and suddenly this latte tastes like you are sitting by a fireplace with a blanket.

What makes this beverage shine is its layered flavor. You get sweet and nutty notes, gentle warmth from the spices, and that familiar espresso base pulling it all together. The oatmilk keeps it light, so you do not feel weighed down like you sometimes do with the pumpkin spice latte. It feels like a drink crafted for those who want fall flavors but not in an over-the-top way.

Still, I will admit this latte is a little niche. Some customers will absolutely adore it, while others might shrug and go back to their classic order. It is not the kind of beverage that sparks an entire cultural moment, but it is solid, satisfying, and perfect for when you need something beyond pumpkin. Think of it as the underdog of the seasonal menu, sneaky good but not the headline act.

2. Pumpkin Spice Latte

Here we are. The legendary, the iconic, the one and only pumpkin spice latte. For years, this classic has ruled the Starbucks autumn drinks menu. Made with steamed milk, strong espresso, sweet pumpkin syrup, and finished with a dusting of spice, it is the definition of cozy. Every sip feels like wrapping yourself in a scarf while pretending you are in a fall movie montage.

The flavor is warm and nostalgic. You taste the pumpkin, the cinnamon, the nutmeg, and yes, the sugar. It is indulgent, but it has earned the right to be indulgent. This is the beverage that built the entire fall season obsession. Without it, there would be no hype, no social media countdowns, no excited customers lined up in august for their first sip of the year. The latte is the blueprint.

But let’s be honest. The pumpkin spice latte has started to feel a little too familiar. It is still delicious, but it is also predictable, the usual order that everyone knows. When you compare it to the newer options, it feels less adventurous. Still, it earns its top-three spot because it is timeless. Love it or roll your eyes at it, the PSL will always be part of the fall menu. It is the icon that refuses to fade.

1. Iced Apple Crisp Oatmilk Shaken Espresso

And at number one, we have the undisputed champion of the fall menu: the iced apple crisp oatmilk shaken espresso. This beverage is perfection in a cup. Bold, complex, refreshing, and cozy all at once, it has taken over as the fresh face of autumn. It starts with the bite of espresso, then layers in oatmilk and sweet apple syrup, shaken to icy smoothness. The result? A drink that tastes like apple pie met your morning coffee and decided to stay forever.

The flavor here is unmatched. You get bright apple, warm cinnamon, a hint of brown sugar, and then the grounding depth of strong coffee. Unlike the pumpkin spice latte, which leans heavy on sweetness, this drink balances it out. It is festive without being cloying, refreshing without feeling summery, and stylish enough that you feel a little cooler just holding it.

This is the drink that redefines what fall at Starbucks can taste like. It is modern, it is fun, and it proves there is life beyond pumpkin. The iced apple crisp oatmilk shaken espresso is not just a seasonal treat; it is the statement piece of the whole menu. If fall were a runway, this would be the closer — confident, unforgettable, and stealing every ounce of attention.

The Starbucks Merch Obsession

Of course, no Starbucks autumn drink and brand craze would be complete without the merch. Let’s be real: the drinks might get you in the door, but those shiny tumblers, mugs, and seasonal cups are what make customers lose their minds. This year’s line is all about deep jewel tones, metallics, and pumpkin-inspired shades that scream, “Take me home, even if I don’t fit in your cabinet.”

People collect these like trading cards, and Starbucks knows it. Every drop sells out in days, sometimes hours, and suddenly you are refreshing eBay to see if you are willing to drop triple the price on a sparkly orange cup. It is ridiculous, it is excessive, and it is exactly why it works. The merch turns a coffee run into a cultural event, giving customers something to show off on Instagram while sipping their latte.

Sure, you do not need another tumbler, but do you want one? Absolutely. The merch has become just as iconic as the drinks themselves, and for some people, it is the real highlight of the season. Let’s be honest: nothing makes your iced apple crisp oatmilk shaken espresso taste better than sipping it out of the newest, trendiest cup.

Personal Picks and Final Thoughts

Now, let’s talk personal preferences, because rankings are fun, but at the end of the day, everyone has their own autumn go-to. Some people will die on the pumpkin spice latte hill, because for them, tradition matters more than novelty. Others are ready to ditch pumpkin entirely and pledge allegiance to the iced apple crisp oatmilk shaken espresso forever. And then there are the bold ones experimenting with the pecan oatmilk cortado, because they want to stand out from the crowd.

The truth is, the “best” fall drink really depends on your mood. Want something cozy and sweet? PSL it is. Need a refreshing but festive caffeine boost? Go for the apple crisp shaken espresso. Craving spice and drama? The iced pumpkin cream chai latte is waiting. That’s the beauty of this seasonal menu — it has range.

But if you ask me, fall is about feeling good, and the best drink is the one that makes you smile as much as it makes you caffeinated. Whether you are sipping the classics or flexing with the trendy newcomers, what really matters is that first moment you take a sip and think, “Yep, fall is here.” And that, my friends, is why Starbucks autumn drinks own the season every single year.

UP NEXT: Movies About Autumn That’ll Ruin Summer For You