Let's Settle This: Which Luxury Mattress Brand Is Best?

For those of us who can’t sleep without a plush pillowtop or a firm-as-a-board surface, it’s nerve-wracking to shell out for a nontoxic mattress that might not hit that certain sweet spot. Thankfully, luxury mattress brands have been making big strides in improving mattress materials without sacrificing comfort. Our WinkBeds vs. Saatva comparison will tell you everything you need to know about these two companies, and which one you should try for yourself. 

While both have several certifications in mattress safety standards, one does shine a bit brighter in that department. Based on sustainability, sleeping positions, and a series of tests, we set out to identify who would benefit most from which mattress.

WinkBeds is an online company creating luxury hybrid mattresses, bed frames, pillows, sheets, and mattress protectors. All its products are all handmade in the United States and sold at relatively affordably prices. The hybrid mattress family holds a CertiPUR-US certification, which is the bare minimum of safety standards. Only the brand's latest model, the EcoCloud, is truly eco-conscious. It has a 100% all-natural latex and innerspring hybrid design and boasts a handful of certifications such as Global Organic Textile Standard, OEKO-TEX, and Rainforest Alliance. If nontoxic materials are your top priority, but you're seeking a cloud-like feel, you'll want to check out the EcoCloud.

WinkBeds mattresses arrive very quickly, within three to five business days. The brand ships its mattresses compressed and rolled in a box—and you’ll be able to sleep on it the day it arrives! Just give the mattress a few hours to expand into its full form.

A luxury nontoxic mattress company with plenty of safety certifications to boot, Saatva is one of the best nontoxic mattress brands you can find. As a member of the Sustainable Furnishings Council, Saatva's materials are GOLS-certified organic, GREENGUARD GOLD, eco-INSTITUT certified, and plant-based. As for manufacturing processes, the brand's plants all operate on solar power. Plus, shipping and delivery processes are designed to minimize Saatva's carbon footprint.

Clearly, Saatva earns points for being sustainable and safe—but something that makes the brand scream “luxury” is its free white glove delivery service. Once you place your order, the mattress will be delivered straight to your home and set up for you. The delivery team will even remove your old mattress if you choose that option upon checkout.

To learn which WinkBeds or Saatva mattress will best suit your sleep style and preferences, here are a couple of factors to consider:

Trial period: WinkBeds has a modest 30-night trial. If you don’t love the mattress, WinkBeds will pick it up for free within the first 30 days. For up to 120 nights, the brand will give you 50% off a new mattress. With Saatva's generous 365-night trial, you have a full year to decide if you like the mattress. If you decide to return it within that timeframe, you'll get a full refund (minus a $99 pick-up fee). If you return it in the first 45 days, the brand will waive the fee.

Firmness: Mattress comfort is subjective, and your body size and sleep position will determine how firm a mattress feels and how well it will keep your spine aligned. WinkBeds and Saatva both offer mattresses with a range of firmness levels. Some, like the Saatva Solaire, even have adjustable firmness.

Materials: When it comes to materials and certifications, Saatva and WinkBeds materials aren’t quite created equal. Saatva is certified organic and safe by GOLS, GREENGUARD GOLD, and eco-INSTITUT and uses biodegradable materials. WinkBeds, on the other hand, only has one mattress in its suite (the EcoCloud) that goes beyond the basic CertiPUR-US certification. The EcoCloud passes our sustainability standards with flying colors.

Our picks for the best WinkBeds and Saatva mattresses:

Best for stomach sleepers: The WinkBed

Pros:

Firm enough for stomach sleepingMultiple firmness options

Sizes Available:

TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King

The original WinkBed mattress is a hybrid design with multiple firmness options to choose from. It’s a top choice for stomach sleepers of all sizes. For larger-bodied people, this mattress comes in “firmer” and “plus," designed to support sleepers with an extra layer of zoned support latex foam and more edge support coils.

It isn’t the most eco-friendly option on our list, but the mattress cover is made with sustainable, eucalyptus-derived Tencel and recycled steel coils. The brand’s materials are CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified.

Read our full review of the original WinkBed, based on a full year of testing.

Best cooling: Saatva Latex Hybrid

Pros:

Breathable and temperature regulatingSupportive for stomach, back, and combination sleepers

Cons:

Not available to ship to Alaska or Hawaii

Sizes Available:

TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia KingSplit California King

This natural latex hybrid mattress is supportive enough for back, stomach, and combination sleepers. It offers above-average temperature regulation in a luxury, eco-friendly design. Thanks to an innerspring base, perforated latex foam, and moisture-wicking wool pillow top, you’ll sleep cool throughout the night.

Note, this mattress is on the firmer side. Latex has a buoyant feel, which can be a deterrent for those who prefer a cloud-like mattress.

Read our in-depth review of the Saatva Latex Hybrid to find out if it's worth the hyper.

Best for back pain: The WinkBed EcoCloud

Pros:

Supportive hybrid designNatural latex & organic cottonCooling

Cons:

Only one firmness optionNo removable cover

Materials:

CertiPUR-US® certified foamsOrganic cottonTalalay latexPocketed coilsMemory foam

Sizes Available:

TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King

If you’re looking for a new mattress in hopes of relieving chronic back pain, you’re in luck. The WinkBed EcoCloud is a hybrid design that eliminates pressure on the joints and back by combining the support of coils with the pressure relief of Talalay latex. It has multiple zones that provide targeted weight distribution for added pressure relief.

Mindbodygreen’s product testers found this mattress to be a true medium, which feels like a 5 out of 10 on a firmness scale. We mainly recommend this mattress for side sleepers who love the feeling of slightly sinking into a cloudlike mattress and for those who could benefit from pressure relief. Another perk? The mattress’ Talalay latex, organic cotton, and all-natural sheep wool are super cooling and breathable.

Read our WinkBeds EcoCloud review.

Best hybrid: Saatva Classic

Pros:

Custom options for firmness and heightGreat for hot sleepersPlush top layer

Cons:

Heavy to lift, but each purchase comes with white glove delivery

Materials:

CertiPUR-US® certified foamsOrganic cottonRecycled steel coils

Sizes Available:

TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingSplit KingCalifornia KingSplit California King

How it arrives:

Free delivery and setup

Best mattress topper: Saatva Latex Mattress Topper

Pros:

Cooling and breathableStraps hold it in placeNatural materials

Cons:

Some might find it too thinSpot-clean only

Materials:

Natural latexOrganic cotton

Sizes Available:

TwinTwin XLFullQueenKingCalifornia King

If your mattress is too soft or firm for your liking and you’re not ready to invest in a new one quite yet, a great mattress topper could be just the luxury upgrade you need (at a much lower cost). This pick is one of the best mattress toppers available today, with a true medium-firm feel.

Latex is naturally cooling, so this topper helps regulate body heat as you sleep. Just like with its mattresses, the brand offers various customizations for this topper. It's recommended to relieve neck, back, and shoulder pain and is more durable and breathable than memory foam toppers.