The Ultimate Thanksgiving Menu Planning Guide (With Recipes)

Little-known fact: my career started in catering. When I moved to Austin at 21, I scored a job as an event planner for a catering company, totally unaware of how much I’d fall in love with the thrill of pulling off high-pressure events. I was new to the city, staying up late at a neighborhood coffee shop, sketching out menus that felt balanced and thoughtful—comforting classics alongside dishes with just enough creativity to surprise guests.

To this day, Thanksgiving menu planning brings out the same spark for me. Designing the meal has become my favorite way to kick off the season—equal parts creativity, strategy, and a little intuition. And if you’ve ever found yourself wondering what dishes really matter, how much food you need, or how to keep things manageable (and delicious), you’re not alone. I hear from so many of you each fall who want Thanksgiving to feel joyful—not overwhelming.

That’s where my tried-and-true Thanksgiving menu formula comes in. It helps me create a balanced meal that checks all the boxes for tradition, flavor, and ease—without cooking enough to feed the neighborhood.

Consider this your blueprint to plan a Thanksgiving menu that feels thoughtful, seasonal, and stress-free.

My biggest tip: intuition + a solid structure.

Thanksgiving is deeply nostalgic—everyone has a dish that means something to them. So yes, honor the family must-haves. But also give yourself permission to edit. For a smaller crowd, you do not need every dish on the table. A thoughtful mix of flavors, textures, and colors will always win over quantity.

Over the years, I’ve landed on a simple formula that keeps me on track and ensures the meal feels abundant, balanced, and achievable (especially if you’re hosting and delegating!).

Use this as your guide, and fill in each category with your favorite recipes—or scroll below for mine.

My Foolproof Thanksgiving Menu Formula

Here’s the structure I return to every single year. Thankfully, most of my family members are great cooks, so I also use this formula to divvy up what people will bring potluck-style.

1. Turkey: Fried, roasted, or smoked. Sometimes we do two—one for the table, one for leftovers.

2. Gravy: Even if it’s not your favorite, it belongs here. Guests expect it, and it ties everything together.

3. Potatoes: Mashed, scalloped, or crispy roasted. (A silky mashed potato never disappoints.)

4. Dressing/Stuffing: Cornbread, sourdough, wild rice, oyster—choose your version and don’t overthink it.

5. An Orange Vegetable Side: Sweet potatoes, butternut squash, honeynut squash, roasted carrots.

6. A Green Vegetable Side: Brussels, green beans, broccolini, sautéed kale, or collards.

7. Bread or Rolls: I usually outsource this part—great bakery rolls or a simple homemade focaccia do the trick.

8. Dessert: At least one pie (pumpkin or pecan are classics), but feel free to add a wild card—apple, buttermilk, or chocolate pie are always welcome.

Hosting tip: If you’re having a smaller gathering, select your favorite five or six categories and let go of the rest. Thoughtful simplicity > an overcrowded table.

Planning Logistics

Let’s talk strategy. Great Thanksgiving menu planning isn’t just about what you serve—it’s when and how you prepare each dish. A little planning goes a long way, and when you map out quantities and make-ahead steps, you’ll step into the holiday relaxed, confident, and actually able to enjoy the day.

Below, I’m sharing a simple guide to portioning your meal and prepping ahead so your kitchen feels intentional, not chaotic.

How Much Food to Make for Thanksgiving

One of the biggest questions I get every year: How much food do I really need? Here’s a simple cheat sheet I rely on:

Turkey: 1–1.5 lbs per person (closer to 1 lb for boneless, 1.5 lbs if bone-in or you want leftovers) Stuffing/Dressing: ½–¾ cup per person Mashed Potatoes: 1 cup per person Gravy: ¼–½ cup per person (more if you’re team “gravy on everything”) Veggie Sides: ½ cup per side, per person (choose two and you’re set) Bread/Rolls: 1–2 per person Pie: 1 slice per person (but we always make enough for two…)

Hosting tip: If you love leftovers, build that into your portions. If you’d rather not eat turkey sandwiches for a week, lean toward the lower end of these estimates.

What You Can Prep Ahead of Time

The secret to a smooth Thanksgiving? Don’t do it all on Thursday. Here’s a helpful breakdown:

2–3 Days Before

Chop onions, herbs, and aromatics Prep stuffing base (bread dried + aromatics sautéed) Make cranberry sauce (it gets better as it chills) Bake any pies that hold well (pecan, apple, chess pies)

Day Before

Prepare casseroles (green beans, sweet potatoes) and refrigerate unbaked Make salad dressing + prep greens Assemble your cheese or snack board ingredients Set the table and label serving dishes

Morning Of

Roast turkey (or reheat if you cooked it the day before—yes, it works!) Bake/reheat casseroles Warm rolls Toss salad and finish garnishes Light candles, turn on music, pour a glass—the fun part begins!

Sanity saver: Label each serving dish with a sticky note (e.g., “mashed potatoes”) so you don’t forget what goes where when it’s go-time. Small detail, big payoff.

Ready to build your menu? Below, you’ll find my favorite Thanksgiving recipes—from mains to sides to pies. Mix and match one dish from each category using the formula above and you’ll have a complete, foolproof Thanksgiving menu with zero guesswork.

Scroll, select, and start planning the most delicious day of the year.

Turkey

Potatoes

Orange Vegetable Side

Dressing/Stuffing

Green Vegetable Side

Pies & Tarts

This post was last updated on November 5, 2025, to include new insights.