This Is The Truth About Facial Toners, From Dermatologists

October 10, 2022 — 11:08 AM

Some skin care products are fairly self-explanatory—take makeup remover, face wash, and moisturizer for example. You can pretty much put two and two together to figure out the basic gist of their function. However more ambiguous steps can make skin care a bit more confusing. 

One prime example: toner. While you may jump to the conclusion that toner is designed to even out skin tone, it’s actually much more complex. Here, find out exactly what toner does, how to pick the best one for your skin type, and a few cult favorites to browse. 

“Toners can have many different functions depending on their active ingredients,” board-certified dermatologist Rebecca Marcus, M.D., FAAD, tells mbg. Think of the word "toner" as an umbrella term encompassing many different, more targeted formulas. 

“Traditionally, toners have been used to remove excess makeup residue and dirt after cleansing,” Marcus explains. “Toners may be formulated with ingredients that serve to soothe, calm, exfoliate, or fight acne, for example,” she continues. 

That said, putting a hard label on the term "toner" doesn’t exactly make sense in the vast world of modern skin care. However, if you'd like a basic definition, just know that toner typically comes in a liquid form and that you can apply it with your hands or a cotton round (opt for reusable rounds to keep your routine eco-friendly). From there, each toner can have a few basic functions.

If you want to add a toner into your routine, there are plenty of grade-A products that will certainly benefit your skin. However, it’s not the most important skin care product out there. (Surely not as vital as a nightly cleanse or daily SPF.) In fact, some experts deem it wholly unnecessary. 

So if you don’t have the time or the budget to incorporate this step, don’t stress it. Many of the ingredients found in toners are included in other serums and moisturizers you may already have in your line-up. 

If you’re going to prioritize your skin care products, definitely pick SPF, cleanser, moisturizer, exfoliants, and retinol over toner. It’s an extra step, sure, but it can be beneficial should you want to explore it. 

Astringents help soak up excess oil production and remove impurities that may have been left behind even after cleansing. Essentially, you can consider them extra-purifying toners, and they're great for those with oily or acne-prone skin. “Be careful not to overdo it, though, as astringent toners often contain alcohol and can be overly drying and disruptive to the skin barrier,” Marcus warns. 

Witch hazel is a popular choice because of its ability to gently balance the skin and regulate sebum production. Again, if you opt for witch hazel toner look for an alcohol-free formula. You can read all about astringents versus toners here.

Essences will generally include ingredients like glycerin, aloe vera, hyaluronic acid, etc. For those with dry skin, an essence will provide a much-needed boost of hydration.

PSA: “While some people prefer one or the other, they can also be used in the same routine–first a toner and then an essence,” Garshick says. Some people even apply multiple layers of an essence (called the "seven skin method") for an extra burst of hydration.

One important caveat:

If you apply a toner of any kind, your skin will be damp for a few moments. If you follow up with a hyaluronic acid serum or moisturizer, this will help those products hydrate the skin even more since humectants love a damp surface. However, it’s important to let your skin dry before applying heavy-duty actives like retinol, which should always be applied to clean, dry skin. 

Shop these toners:

Renee Rouleau

Elderberry Soothing Toner 

$39

Versed

Weekend Glow Daily Brightening Toner

$18

Peach & Lily

Wild Dew Treatment Essence

$39