The Surface Laptop Studio 2 looks great, but is it better than Dell’s XPS 15?

Microsoft’s premier 2-in-1 laptop, the Surface Laptop Studio, just got refreshed, and it has had its performance quotient upped significantly. We compared the first generation to the Dell XPS 13 based on size, but the Surface Laptop Studio 2 deserves to be mentioned in the same breath as much faster machines.

That includes the Dell XPS 15, a larger machine, but one that’s similarly configured to the Surface Laptop Studio 2. The Dell is on our list of best laptops, so it’s formidable competition. Will the Surface Laptop Studio 2 keep up by the time it’s released?

Specs and configurations

The Dell XPS 15 starts at $1,499 for a Core i7-13700H CPU, 16GB of RAM, a 512GB SSD, a 15.6-inch Full HD+ IPS display, and an Intel Arc A370M GPU. Fully configured, it costs $4,349 for a Core i9-13900H, 64GB of RAM, an 8TB SSD, a 15.6-inch 3.5K OLED display, and an Nvidia GeForce RTX 4070.

The Surface Laptop Studio 2 starts out at a higher price: $2,000 for a Core i7-13700H, 16GB of RAM, a 512GB SSD, and a 14.4-inch PixelSense IPS display. The most expensive configuration is $3,700 for a Core i7-13700H, 64GB of RAM, a 2TB SSD, and an RTX 4060 GPU.

The XPS 15 is more expensive at the high end, but that’s with significantly upgraded components. Both are expensive machines, but for what you get in terms of specs, the Surface Laptop Studio 2 is the more expensive laptop.

Design

The Surface Laptop Studio 2 sports an unusual design, even among 2-in-1 laptops. It utilizes a “pull-forward” mechanism, meaning its display can be used in a normal clamshell configuration or pulled forward into what Microsoft calls Studio mode, where the display sits at an angle covering the keyboard while leaving the touchpad available for use, or Tablet mode, a more traditional 2-in-1 format. The XPS 15 is a traditional clamshell laptop through and through. That makes the Surface Laptop Studio 2 a much more flexible machine with a ton of additional uses, particularly when you’re using the Microsoft Surface Pen to write and draw on the display.

Microsoft’s machine is also a lot more modern in its design. While it maintains the same look as the previous generation, that aesthetic seems more futuristic than the XPS 15’s, which also hasn’t changed for a few generations. The XPS 15 is an attractive laptop, no doubt, with its silver aluminum base and black carbon fiber keyboard deck, but the Surface Laptop Studio’s all-aluminum chassis and innovative display design give it a more futuristic feel. Both are incredibly well-built, though, and so you won’t be choosing between these machines based on build quality.

Both laptops also have excellent keyboards, with plenty of travel, large comfortable keycaps, tons of key spacing, and switches that are precise and snappy. The Surface Laptop Studio 2’s touchpad is quite a bit smaller than the XPS 15’s, but it’s a haptic version that provides all the advantages of that technology such as clicking on the entire surface. The XPS 15’s mechanical version is huge and responsive, but haptic touchpads are more efficient.

Connectivity is close to a tie, with both offering a mix of Thunderbolt 4 and legacy ports. We prefer the full-sized SD card reader in the XPS 15 to the Surface Laptop Studio 2’s microSD card reader. Dell is a generation behind in wireless connectivity.

Another win for the Surface Laptop Studio 2 is in its 1080p webcam. The XPS 15 is stuck with a 720p version, and while we haven’t tested Microsoft’s webcam, we’re certain it will provide a superior image.

Performance

The XPS 15 is a thin and light 15-inch laptop that compromises a bit on performance to fit everything into its chassis. It offers fast components, including up to the 45-watt Core i9-13900H and the Nvidia GeForce RTX 4070, but thermal issues exist that limit performance and Dell serious underclocked the RTX 4070. Even so, the XPS 15 performs well for both the most demanding productivity users and all but professional creators.

We haven’t tested the Surface Laptop Studio 2 yet, but it now offers the 45-watt Core i7-13700H, which in other laptops has provided solid productivity and creative performance. And it can be purchased with the RTX 4060, a much faster GPU than was available in the previous generation. There’s also an option for an Nvidia RTX 2000 Ada, which is aimed at professional applications and promises performance similar to the RTX 4060.

Most likely, these two laptops will provide similar performance, but we need to wait to test the Surface Laptop Studio 2 ourselves.

Display

The Surface Laptop Studio 2 offers a single display option, the 14.4-inch PixelSense IPS display with a very tall 3:2 aspect ratio, a resolution of 2,400 x 1,600, and a fast refresh rate of 120Hz. It will probably be unchanged from the previous generation’s display, which offered tons of brightness and good contrast, but average color width and good accuracy. The display supports both touch and Microsoft’s excellent Surface Pen.

The XPS 15 has two displays available. The pedestrian 15.6-inch 16:10 Full HD+ IPS display is for those looking to save some money and who don’t need wide colors or deep contrast. Also available is a 3.5K OLED panel that offers good brightness, very wide and accurate colors, and inky blacks. Both displays run at just 60Hz, but for creators, the OLED panel is the winner here. Note that while the XPS 15’s OLED display supports touch, neither display offers pen support.

Portability

The Surface Laptop Studio 2 is narrower than the XPS 15, but it’s just as deep, thicker, and heavier. That’s because of the pull-forward display, which increases complexity and pushes out the palm rest. Neither is a particularly portable laptop.

In terms of battery life, the first-gen Surface Laptop Studio had better battery life than the latest XPS 15, by a couple of hours in our web-browsing and video-looping tests. That’s surprising given the much smaller battery in Microsoft’s 2-in-1. We’ll have to wait until we test it to see if the newer model, with its more powerful components, can maintain the same margin.

The Surface Laptop Studio 2 is a more modern and flexible machine

Based on what we know, the Surface Laptop Studio 2 wins out thanks to a much more modern design that offers superior flexibility. You can simply do more with Microsoft’s machine, particularly if you’re one who likse to take digital notes and draw on a display.

Of course, performance and battery life will matter. So, we’ll reserve final judgment until we’re able to test the Surface Laptop Studio 2. We’ll update this comparison once we’ve put the machine through our suite of benchmarks.

Editors' Recommendations